Saturday, September 21, 2013

TFA, the best choice after college?

I was familiar with the name of Teach for America, as well as City Year. Both programs, on the surface, are programs that seem to fit my aspirations. I am honestly passionate about inner city/troubled districts. Between coming from a small town with a failing school and spending time volunteering in Columbus City schools, I have a heart for the kids. I want to meet the needs of the students I will one day have in my own class room, and I often think that the educational system needs to be reformed. As for my role in this, I have always thought as my role strictly being to reform the shape of a classroom from within.
Because I am so interested in meeting the needs in "difficult" places, and college does not equip students to be come teachers, TFA and CY have always seemed like the next step after college.
After our guest speaker from TFA (who spoke very well and I believed to be genuine in her answers), I realize that TFA is not an option for me. I am not seeking a stepping stone or a completion of a "good deed." I actually want to make a career out of serving a school with my passion and effort, not give two years of my time. While TFA makes it possible for people to stay in education after 2 years, I feel that the reform that TFA is initiating may not be the reform education needs.
This is separate from TFA completely, but it reminds me of my current impression of the program...I met another student and we discussed our majors. She was something like "education policy" and that excited me because I, too, want to be a teacher. But she quickly addressed this excitement with "Oh, I would never be a teacher, I just think there needs to be a change in the way we do education." It was frustrating for me to realize that this woman may play a crucial part in how I run my classroom one day, yet she will never spend time with students like I will. So my impression of TFA tells me that the program is creating people who are passionate about changing education, but in a more "hands off" approach. Yes, these participants are going to be spending two years in a classroom, but usually to leave for a better paying career or to serve the educational system outside of the classroom (ie: our guest speaker said she most likely will never teach again, but is studying education). Possibly, she will be on the forefront of future changes. But is 2 years in a classroom and a degree enough to provoke proper change?
The TFA representative also mention the constant change and growth that TFA experiences.This blog post http://garyrubinstein.teachforus.org/2011/10/31/why-i-did-tfa-and-why-you-shouldnt/ hits on one man's perspective on TFA and he talks a lot about what the changes and growth have done to make the program worse in addition to some other arguments he has about TFA.

1 comment:

  1. I think this a very interesting look on TFA! I also most definitely agree that I do not think TFA is for people who actually want to become a part of the teaching profession. It seems to me that most people that do it from what I've heard are not actively involved in wanting to become a teacher. I think it is very selfless and heartless to dedicate two years of your time to moving to a new environment, teaching students and becoming actively involved in their community. However, I think it is true passion that fuels dedicating your whole life and career to generations of children. Also, in trying to complete your Bachelor's degree in the four year licensing program that OSU now offers, TFA seems like it would only inhibit your time and set you further back with deadlines and whatnot that are important to actually obtaining a teaching degree. Although it is true that no college class or student teaching can fully prepare you for actually teaching a classroom, I think it still offers us insight to what the career entails. It is natural when talking about any future career to be slightly unprepared, however as long as you have the passion it will keep you going through the struggles and accomplishments. In short, TFA to me sounds like a great idea, but in practice it is just a little short of what it hopes to be.

    ReplyDelete